If Mary, Did You Know had been written by a woman…

It’s stereotypical, but true: Men are thinkers. Women are feelers.

Studies show men have greater problem solving abilities and more cognitive flexibility which can lead to greater resilience and positive moods. But women’s reactions to stress make it harder for us to navigate our thinking during difficult times. And this can result in mood fluctuations.

Sound familiar?

Our feelings can get in the way of our thoughts.

In fact, our feelings sometimes become our thoughts. And, if we’re honest with ourselves, we’ve even had moments when we don’t care about logic, facts, or reason at all. Because the only thing that matters in this moment is how I’m feeling!

And ladies, we can feel really big, can’t we?

A few years ago, I entered into the Christmas season with big feelings. Emotions too unruly to stuff neatly into a stocking and too heavy to hang safely from the mantle.

When the now-classic song, “Mary, Did You Know?” came on the radio for the hundredth time that season, I scoffed. You know how you can tell this song was written by a man? I thought.

Because if a woman had written it, it would be titled, Mary, Did You Feel?

That year, I went on a mission. I read through the Gospels with one question on my heart – what might Mary have felt as the mother of Jesus? Was she so holy that she didn’t have feelings? Or was she a woman, like me – like us – who had to wrestle with hormones and emotions and questions and confusion?

The Bible leaves so much unsaid. But if Mark Lowry could ask what Mary knew, I could imagine what she might be feeling. Perhaps you’d like to imagine with me.

Mary, Did You Feel?

“Mary, Did You Know?” Original lyrics by Mark Lowry. Music by Buddy Greene. Rewritten lyrics by Emily E. Ryan.

 

Mary did you feel that your closest friends would one day walk right by you?
Mary did you feel that your dearest love might even say goodbye too?
Did you feel that your growing waist would make the people talk?
The blessing you’ve been given is a curse out of wedlock.

Mary did you feel that your hopes and dreams would disappear like rainbows?
Mary did you feel that your challenges would follow you like shadows?
Did you feel like forgotten sheep when lying on the hay?
When you screamed into the darkness, did you wish for yesterday?

The men will ask. The world will doubt. So few will understand.
It won’t make sense. And most won’t sing the praises of God’s plan.

Mary did you feel that your legacy would always invite sorrow?
Mary did you feel that your heart and arms would be empty tomorrow?
Did you feel that the angel’s song would fade among the lost?
The sleeping child you’re holding will die upon a cross.

Mary did you feel?

This is an excerpt from my Christmas message Once Upon a Christmas. Click here for a full list of my holiday messages or to check my speaking availability for next year.